California is Closing Early

Why our once-vibrant after-hours economy is changing – and what we’re losing along the way

 

Imagine grabbing a bite at a neighborhood diner at 2 a.m. It’s late at night – or early in the morning – depending upon how you look at life.

A waitress refills your coffee. At the next table, a tech worker is on a graveyard shift lunch break.  Across the restaurant, twenty-somethings are coming home from a night of dancing.  Another diner is eating breakfast six hours early.

Consider Southern California’s iconic Norms chain, whose La Cienega location still serves customers around the clock under the slogan “Where Life Happens.”  Its late-night menu ranges from hotcakes to T-bone steak and eggs to “The Clubhouse” sandwich.

But the landmark diner faces an uncertain future. Raising Cane’s purchased the building and proposed converting the landmark building into a chicken restaurant – including putting its name on the iconic sign. The company withdrew their initial plans amid community opposition but still owns the building.

The potential closure is part of a larger Southern California trend – Los Angeles lost 35 percent of its 24-hour restaurants between February 2020 and February 2024 according to Yelp data provided to KCRW Radio.

Restaurants are also pulling down the shades earlier in the evening, too.  Imagine trying to get something to eat at a restaurant at 8:45 PM, only to be turned away because it is closing at 9.

Industry researchers Datassential found that nearly 57 percent of American restaurants were still open at 9:45 PM as of 2019 – but that figure had fallen to just 41.5 by 2022.  Nearly 6 in 10 restaurants overall had shortened their operating hours.

California helped pioneer the culture of 24-hour convenience.

Now, despite all of our technology and prosperity, many of the places where we once enjoyed that convenience have shorter hours.

When did 9 PM become the new midnight?

Nationwide, Denny’s, whose slogan used to emphasize that the restaurant was “Always Open,” reported in October 2024 that just 75 percent of its restaurants had returned back to 24-hour service compared to before the pandemic.

Meanwhile, Walmart, once a dependable destination for post-midnight shopping, eliminated round-the-clock stores during the pandemic and confirmed in June 2024 that there were “no current plans to return our stores to 24 hours of operations.”

Sure, the COVID-19 pandemic forced many businesses to cut their hours. Grocers, in particular, used the late-night hours to restock and sanitize their stores.

However, when the restrictions disappeared, some businesses discovered that overnight service no longer justified the costs.

Much of the problem centers around labor.

Keeping a restaurant open at 2 a.m. means paying a cook, server, dishwasher and perhaps a security guard – even if only three customers order pancakes.

California’s minimum wage for fast food restaurant employees is $20 per hour. Do the math. A restaurant staffing three employees for a six-hour overnight shift would spend $360 on wages alone, or $131,400 annually – before taxes, benefits, and other expenses including food and energy.

Nationally, restaurant operating expenses increased roughly 36 percent across the country between 2019 and 2026, according to the National Restaurant Association. And 42 percent of surveyed operators said their restaurants were not profitable in 2025.

Finding workers is another challenge. In a 2025 survey, 77 percent of restaurant operators cited recruiting and retaining employees as a leading challenge. Filling overnight shifts can be harder still.

While many of these challenges are from government regulations, San Francisco has gone a step further.

In parts of the Tenderloin and South of Market areas, the city has actually passed regulations outlawing certain food and tobacco establishments from operating between midnight and 5 a.m., with shorter restrictions for businesses with alcohol licenses.

Officials cite public safety. But if a neighborhood has a crime problem, should the solution be to make legitimate businesses close earlier?

Perhaps the biggest change here is in how Californians shop.

With DoorDash, Instacart and other delivery services, customers can order dinner or groceries without leaving home – sometimes even overnight.

DoorDash reported a 36 percent year-over-year increase in orders placed between midnight and 5 a.m. in 2023. Its 2026 workplace trends report found that the Bay Area led the nation’s major markets in the share of late-night workplace meal orders for companies placed after 6 p.m.

We don’t need government to preserve every 24-hour diner. If customer habits change, businesses should be free to adapt. But government shouldn’t unnecessarily increase the cost of keeping businesses open or prohibit legitimate commerce without compelling justification.

There was something wonderfully American knowing that the neighborhood diner was always open. Someone had a business to run. Someone else wanted pancakes at 3 a.m. Neither cared what time it was.

So, maybe the old 24-hour diner wasn’t much to look at. The coffee was usually average at best, but late-night dining always offers great people watching.

Maybe America’s appetite for late-night convenience hasn’t disappeared. Maybe we’ve just traded the fluorescent lights of the all-night diner for the glow of a smartphone.


Tim Anaya is the Pacific Research Institute’s vice president of marketing and communications and co-author of The California Left Coast Survivor’s Guide.

 

 

Scroll to Top