You’d think for all the criticism heaped upon famed economist Milton Friedman he might have actually said business is about making profits and nothing else.
But that’s not what he said.
This misunderstanding stalks me. It’s everywhere. I’m sick of it.
Friedman won a Nobel Prize in 1976 for breakthrough thinking in monetary policy and the role government action plays in extending recessions, and he was arguably the most influential economist over the past century.
But for all his greatness, Friedman gets a disproportionate amount of attention for writing a 1970 New York Times essay titled: “The Social Responsibility of Business Is to Increase its Profits.” It was written largely as a critique of executives imposing their own “social responsibility” goals upon a business without the consent of ownership, and pointed to the “G.M. crusade,” a shareholder campaign at the time backed by Ralph Nader, pushing business to enact social change. As Friedman saw it, businessmen and shareholders were experts in running companies, not fighting social ills through businesses.
In his condemnation of the trend, Friedman wrote that instead of pushing for their own desires for social change, they should instead pursue the goals of the owners, “which generally will be to make as much money as possible while conforming to their basic rules of the society, both those embodied in law and those embodied in ethical custom.”
Critics only seem to remember the first part about making money and entirely ignore the second part about ethics and laws and totally dismiss the broader context.
Here’s former President Barack Obama in 2023: “For more than 50 years, corporate managers have embraced the view popularized by Milton Friedman, that their only responsibility is to increase shareholder value. That’s all.”
But no, Mr. President, that’s not all.
I ran across the Obama quote on X recently when Independent Institute scholar Phil Magness attributed it as a joke to Vice President JD Vance in an effort to highlight how far left the right has moved on free markets. Vance didn’t say it, but I had to at least double check, which showed how widespread this faulty understanding of Friedman’s philosophy is.
Friedman came up again a month or so ago while I was reading “Counterfeit Gods,” a 2009 book on idolatry by the late pastor Tim Keller, whom I adore. Keller was writing about corporate greed and recalled an article at that time in The Economist that “evoked Milton Friedman’s claim that business managers have one and only one goal – to maximize shareholder value.”
Wrong! Friedman said executives are there to implement the desires of the owners – because the owners own the company – and that goal is usually to make a profit (with all the ethical and legal disclaimers). Friedman also said that the owners could decide to deviate from solely making a profit if and when they want to. Friedman correctly acknowledged that business owners could add value in lots of ways.
But perhaps the most popular critique of Friedman’s shareholder theory was something I ran across in my MBA coursework by libertarian Whole Foods founder John Mackey, who in 2005 wrote: “In 1970 Milton Friedman wrote that ‘there is one and only one social responsibility of business-to use its resources and engage in activities designed to increase its profits so long as it stays within the rules of the game, which is to say, engages in open and free competition without deception or fraud.’ That’s the orthodox view among free market economists: that the only social responsibility a law-abiding business has is to maximize profits for the shareholders. I strongly disagree.”
Mackey lists the ways he ran his then-company, whose stores I visit constantly, by creating value for six constituencies: “customers, team members (employees), investors, vendors, communities, and the environment.”
It’s great that Mackey valued those things while leading Whole Foods, but it’s a bit of a strawman argument since Friedman never said treat your employees like dirt, bleed your customers dry and poison rivers. Friedman wrote as much in a response to Mackey, noting that he and Mackey were essentially in agreement and that Whole Foods was run in accordance with the principles for which Friedman advocated in his essay.
The point Friedman was ultimately trying to make is lost in this whole debate, and that’s the question of who actually owns the company, which is, of course, the owners, and not executives bit by the do-gooder bug or minor shareholders looking to focus businesses on things that have nothing to do with business.
After giving a list of examples, including the one of Nader and G.M., Friedman wrote: “In each of these cases, the corporate executive would be spending someone else’s money for a general social interest. Insofar as his actions in accord with his ‘social responsibility’ reduce returns to stockholders, he is spending their money. Insofar as his actions raise the price to customers, he is spending the customers’ money. Insofar as his actions lower the wages of some employees, he is spending their money.”
Friedman was fighting socialism and the foolish notion that labor and outside groups owned the company. They don’t. Friedman was also diligently showing that the actions of non-owners or activists who owned twelve shares out of hundreds of millions might have been well-intentioned but were actually robbing from customers, owners and employees.
It’s a nuance that’s lost today. I highlighted just a few examples, but you’ll see the critique running through lines of logic in current economic debates. And the truth is, they’re not necessarily wrong – I mean, they are wrong by misquoting Friedman, but they’re not wrong that there are a lot of poorly run businesses that are only in it to make fast money. Many examples come to mind, but, of course, no industry has a monopoly on bad actors.
But it is their right to run their businesses as they see fit (as long as it’s legal and ethical). It’s also a right of stakeholders to vote with their wallets and find businesses they want to support.
If more people actually read what Friedman wrote and didn’t simply quote people misquoting him, they might actually learn a lot about economics and how to run a business.
Matt Fleming, MBA, is communications director and a policy fellow at the Pacific Research Institute.